SATA Hard Drive Buying Guide

The Differences between ATA, PATA, and SCSI Storage Devices

© Chad Criswell

Aug 10, 2007
A Parallel ATA style Hard Drive Connection, Western Digital
Buying a new SATA hard drive is confusing if you don't understand the differences between the various drive types. Which hard drive should you buy?

SATA Hard Drives (Serial ATA) are the most popular drives being sold today. Alongside them in the store however you will also find boxes labeled Parallel ATA or SCSI. So what are the differences between these hard drives and which one should you purchase? Your decision is dictated by what your computer can accept. Check with your computer's manufacturer to see which drive style you can use. Most newer computers purchased within the last two years accept SATA connections. If your computer cannot accept one of the newer SATA hard drives you can purchase SATA adaptor cards that plug into an empty expansion slot on your computer's motherboard. You can purchase SCSI adaptors as well, so follow these tips to guide your decision.

SATA vs PATA: Serial ATA vs. Parallel ATA Drives

SATA hard drives have many benefits over their older cousin, the Parallel ATA drive. Chief among these differences are:

  • SATA hard drives are faster and perform much better than traditional ATA drives and are better for high bandwidth applications such as video editing and multiplayer gaming.
  • SATA drives use a smaller, cheaper cable to connect to the computer's motherboard. These cables can also be up to three feet in length compared to eighteen inches with Parallel ATA cables.
  • SATA hard drives can be hot swappable, meaning that they can be disconnected and reconnected without powering down the computer. There are limits to this of course. You should never disconnect your boot drive while the computer is operating.
  • SATA cables are easier to plug in without damaging the delicate connecting pins on the drive.
  • SATA hard drives are significantly faster than external USB hard drives.

SCSI Hard Drives

SCSI hard drives are the elders of the storage world. SCSI is one of the oldest specifications but it is also the fastest and thus has been widely used in network servers and other high speed, high bandwidth applications. Unfortunately this high speed storage has also meant much higher costs. SCSI drives were once standard in all Macintosh computers but have since been replaced by the cheaper SATA based hard drives.

  • SCSI drives are also hot swappable, similar to the SATA drives.
  • Some varieties of SCSI can be used with SATA
  • SCSI drives are often set up in a mirroring arrangment to allow for instant, continuous backups of the hard drives.
  • SCSI drives are still the most expensive drives on the consumer market.

Your basic rule of thumb should be to purchase a drive that is designed to work with your computer's motherboard. Try to avoid using SCSI adaptors or SATA adaptors unless absolutely necessary as the whole point of using a specific kind of hard drive is to get the most speed and storage for the money.


The copyright of the article SATA Hard Drive Buying Guide in Computer Drives/Storage is owned by Chad Criswell. Permission to republish SATA Hard Drive Buying Guide in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.


A Parallel ATA style Hard Drive Connection, Western Digital
       


Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo

Comments
Oct 15, 2008 10:42 PM
Guest :
pata is old technology sata is today generation we can say that sata is advance technology
Nov 26, 2008 8:55 PM
Guest :
anyone know of an adapter to change a SATA drive to a PATA drive?
admin@eternalwolf.net
Mar 1, 2009 7:33 PM
Guest :
SATA, ATA, SCSI are all obsolete except for the Terabyte SATAS.

one word. SOLID STATE HD's. <--- Great for a boot HD and main HD plus can't compare speeds to the others.
Apr 13, 2009 8:02 PM
Guest :
what are you going to use a terabyte for ???? OVERKILL
Apr 20, 2009 9:27 PM
Guest :
so can a SATA be a solid state hd?
May 25, 2009 4:45 PM
Guest :
Can someone please highlight how do I know whether my desktop accepts USB external hard disk?

thanks
Jun 21, 2009 12:39 AM
Guest :
Terabyte? Overkill?? Three words - Home HD Video!!! (or 4 year's worth of 10 MPx camera shots!)
Jun 24, 2009 3:13 AM
Guest :
To answer the first question, Do you have a USB connection? If so, your desktop will accept the drive. I would recommend a USB 2.0 drive and connector though,as the original USB is way too slow. Second question...SATA can be solid state. SATA just means that it conforms to the specifications for the connector. Terabyte = Overkill? I think not. I store digital copies of my blu-ray movies and use it to play them on a big screen. I have 4 terabyte drives that are almost full. (In the early 90's they used to say that a 200 MB drive was overkill BTW.) Solid state drives are nice, but have some serious limitations. Flash-memory cells can wear out after 1,000 to 10,000 write cycles for MLC, and up to 100,000 write cycles for SLC. Slower write speeds: As erase blocks on flash-based SSDs generally are quite large (e.g. 0.5 - 1 megabyte)[18], they are far slower than conventional disks during small writes (write amplification effect) and can suffer from write fragmentation. Recent SSDs mitigate this problem using large DRAM write buffers and intelligent controllers. Also, modern copy-on-write or log-structured file systems (e.g., btrfs or NILFS) write linearly to the disk, not triggering the write amplification effect. SSDs based on DRAM, which do this several orders of magnitude faster than conventional disks though, do not suffer from this problem. DRAM-based SSDs require more power than hard disks, when operating; and they still use power when the computer is turned off, while hard disks do not. They are also significantly more expensive than mechanical drives. SSD is still currently a developing technology. A January 2009 review of the market by technology reviewer Tom's Hardware concluded that comparatively few of the tested devices showed acceptable I/O performance, with several disappointments.
Jul 11, 2009 8:13 AM
Guest :
New WINDOWS 7 has an automatic back up feature that copies the entire desktop configuration as a compressed image file.
34GB of data requires at least 3GB of free space to back up and recommended setting is for a separate internal drive. Externals can be used but WINDOWS warns that swapping the external to another system (portable music/gaming/video storage use) can corrupt the back up data ini file.
Great reason to have a second drive inside.
Sep 4, 2009 7:17 AM
Guest :
In a few years you'll need a terrabyte to run your Windows bloatware. There's no escaping it.
Oct 21, 2009 7:19 PM
Guest :
im having trouble finding a laptop with a SSD anyone have any suggestions as to what brand/ make of laptop includes it?
Oct 29, 2009 6:34 PM
Guest :
I ORDERED A 250GB ATA/100 7200 RPM 8.9MS 8MG
I RECIEVED A 250GB PATA / 8MG CACHE
WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE

I WANT TO REPLACE THE STOCK 80.0GB ULTRA DMA 5400 RPM
12 Comments